Gutters
Ice Dams and Gutters: What Clean Gutters Can and Can't Prevent
Do gutters cause ice dams? No, but a packed gutter makes one worse. What causes ice dams in the Colorado foothills, how to handle one safely, and what to fix.
Not on their own. An ice dam starts on the roof, when snow on the upper slope melts and the water refreezes at the eave, and that happens to houses with spotless gutters and to houses with no gutters at all. What a clean gutter does is give the meltwater somewhere to go on the days it can drain, and stop a trough full of needles from turning into a shelf where more ice can build.
So if you’ve been told gutters cause ice dams, that’s backwards. But a neglected gutter is part of why some dams get so big.
What causes an ice dam
Snow sits on the roof. Something warms the upper part of it: heat escaping from the living space into the attic, mostly, and up here at 7,000 feet in Evergreen, plain winter sun on a dark roof, which can start melt even on a day when the air never gets above freezing. The water runs down under the snowpack until it reaches the eave, which hangs out past the warm walls and stays as cold as the air. There it freezes.
Do that for a few days and the frozen edge grows into a ridge. Water arriving from above now pools behind it, and a pool on a sloped roof finds its way under the shingles, through the decking and into the ceiling. That’s the leak people find in February, usually as a brown stain near an outside wall.
Where the gutter comes in
A gutter packed with pine needles and roof grit can’t drain, so the water in it freezes solid. That frozen trough becomes an extension of the eave: one more cold surface for the dam to grow along, and one that adds a lot of weight. Ice is heavy, and a gutter hung to carry water was never meant to carry a solid block of it. That’s how sections pull away from the fascia.
Downspouts tend to go first. A downspout half full of needles freezes into a plug early in the season, and after that the whole run backs up no matter how clean the trough above it is. When we clean gutters we check that water actually leaves through the downspout for exactly this reason.
How to tell if you have one
Thick icicles all along the gutter line are the usual first sign, though icicles on their own don’t prove much; a lot of foothills houses grow a few every winter without a problem. The stronger signs are a raised ridge of ice along the edge of the roof with snow piled behind it, ice built up inside the gutter, and water stains or damp patches at the top of an exterior wall during a cold snap.
What to do when there’s already a dam
Stay off the roof. Ice on a sloped roof is how people get hurt, and chipping at a dam with a hammer or a hatchet breaks shingles and punctures the gutter.
What works from the ground is a roof rake: pull the bottom three or four feet of snow off the roof after each storm, and there’s less snow left to melt into the dam. If water is already coming inside, call a roofer or a crew that steams ice dams off. Removing ice dams isn’t work we do, and it’s a job for someone with the right equipment rather than a ladder and a mallet.
Fixing it for next winter
The lasting fix is usually in the attic. Warm air leaking up through light fixtures and ceiling gaps, thin insulation, and poor ventilation all heat the underside of the roof, and a roofer or an energy auditor can tell you which of those your house has. Heat cable along the eave is a workaround: it melts a channel so water can drain through the dam, which helps, but it treats the symptom and it only works if the gutter and downspout it drains into are clear.
The gutter side is simpler. Clear the trough and the downspouts in late autumn, after the needles finish dropping and before the first hard freeze, so the first thaw of the season has an open path off the roof. Our post on when to clean gutters in the foothills explains why ponderosa and lodgepole make that timing different up here.
Getting the gutters done before the freeze
We clean gutters across Evergreen, Conifer, Golden and Bailey, and in Highlands Ranch, Centennial, Littleton and Lakewood. We take the debris out by hand, including the compacted layer at the bottom, and we don’t call a gutter done until we’ve watched it drain through the downspout.
Request a gutter cleaning quote with your address and how many stories the house is, and you’ll get a straight price back from a real person. If the windows need doing too, mention it, since the ladder’s already up.
Quick answers
- Do clean gutters prevent ice dams?
- Not on their own. An ice dam forms when snow on the upper roof melts and the water refreezes at the cold eave, and that happens on houses with spotless gutters and on houses with no gutters at all. A clean gutter gives meltwater somewhere to go on days it can drain, and keeps a packed trough from becoming a shelf for more ice.
- Do gutters cause ice dams?
- No. The cause is heat, from the house or from strong sun, melting snow above an eave that stays below freezing. Gutters full of needles and frozen water make the dam bigger and heavier, which is how gutters get pulled off the fascia, but they don't start it.
- How do you get rid of an ice dam safely?
- From the ground. Pull the bottom few feet of snow off the roof with a roof rake after each storm, and leave the ice itself to a roofer or an ice dam steaming crew if it's leaking. Chipping at it with a hammer or a hatchet breaks shingles, and an icy roof is no place to stand.
- Does heat tape stop ice dams?
- It keeps a channel open so meltwater can drain through the dam, which can stop a leak. It doesn't stop the dam from forming, and it doesn't work if the gutter and downspout it drains into are packed or frozen.